
Natural diamonds have been treasured for generations for their beauty, rarity, and enduring symbolism. Formed deep within the earth over billions of years, each natural diamond is a remarkable product of nature and a unique representation of life’s most meaningful moments.
At McCoy Jewelers, we offer a carefully curated selection of natural diamonds in a variety of shapes, sizes, and qualities. Whether you’re searching for a classic round brilliant diamond, an elegant oval, a timeless emerald cut, or a distinctive fancy shape, our team can help you find the perfect diamond for your engagement ring. If we do not have the perfect natural diamond for you, we are able to bring a selection specifically for you to select from.

What is a Natural Diamond?
A natural diamond is a gemstone formed deep within the earth under extreme heat and pressure. Over billions of years, carbon atoms bond together in a crystal lattice structure, creating one of the hardest and most brilliant materials found in nature.
After being brought closer to the earth’s surface through volcanic activity, diamonds are mined, cut, polished, and transformed into the beautiful stones used in fine jewelry today.
The Rarity of a Natural Diamond
Many people associate natural diamonds with rarity, but the story is a little more complex than a simple yes or no answer. Natural diamonds are remarkable because they were formed by nature over billions of years and can only be found in certain parts of the world. While diamonds are discovered through mining, only a small percentage have the beauty, clarity, and quality needed to become fine jewelry.
At the same time, the diamond industry has played a role in shaping how consumers view diamonds. Throughout much of the twentieth century, major companies such as De Beers controlled a significant portion of the diamond supply entering the market, thus controlling the ‘rarity’ and prices of natural diamonds.
Today, consumers have more information and more choices than ever before. For many people, the appeal of a natural diamond isn’t simply about rarity; it’s about owning a unique piece of nature with a story. Whether you choose a natural diamond or a lab grown diamond, both are beautiful options. The right choice comes down to your personal preferences, priorities, and what feels most meaningful to you.

Why Choose a Natural Diamond?
Many couples choose natural diamonds because of their remarkable journey and natural origin.
Natural diamonds are often chosen for:
• Their natural origin
• Their unique geological history
• Their ‘rarity’ and limited supply
• Their timeless symbolism
For couples who value tradition, rarity, and a connection to nature, a natural diamond remains a meaningful choice.

Designing a Custom Natural Diamond Engagement Ring
Our team will help you compare diamond shapes, understand the Four Cs, and discover the characteristics that matter most to you. Whether you’re searching for a timeless round brilliant, an elegant oval, or a one-of-a-kind fancy shape, we’ll help you find a natural diamond that reflects your style and priorities.
At McCoy Jewelers, you can choose from hundreds of engagement ring styles or create a custom ring designed around the natural diamond you love most.
Why Buy a Natural Diamond from McCoy Jewelers?
✓ Compare Diamonds Side-by-Side
See natural diamonds in person and understand how cut, color, clarity, and carat weight impact their appearance.
Learn about the 4 Cs, here.
✓ Private Bridal Salon
Take your time exploring diamonds and engagement rings in a comfortable, pressure-free environment.
✓ Hundreds of Engagement Ring Styles
Pair your natural diamond with a ready-to-propose ring, a customizable mounting, or a fully custom design.
✓ Family-Owned Since 1973
For more than 50 years, McCoy Jewelers has helped couples throughout the Tri-State area celebrate life’s biggest moments.
✓ Expert Care After the Proposal
From cleanings and inspections to repairs and maintenance, our team is here long after your purchase.
✓ Local Expertise You Can Trust
Work directly with experienced jewelry professionals who can answer questions and guide you through every step of the process.
At McCoy Jewelers, we believe choosing a natural diamond should be exciting, educational, and personal. Our goal is to help you find a diamond you’ll love for a lifetime while providing the service and support that online retailers simply can’t match.

